Grilled Potatoes Anna…and San Diego’s Brooklyn Girl!

Potatoes, butter, salt and pepper — that’s all it apparently takes to get me very excited about a side dish! I was inspired to make today’s Grilled Potatoes Anna on the panini press after tasting the Pommes Anna (the Frenchier name for it) at Brooklyn Girl, a popular new(ish) restaurant in the Mission Hills neighborhood of San Diego. My husband, Mike, and I were there to preview their prix fixe menu lineup for San Diego Restaurant Week, which runs next week (Jan 19-24, 2014).

Read on to see the highlights from our terrific dinner at Brooklyn Girl, and my recipe for a simply delicious side dish on your panini press, Grilled Potatoes Anna!

Mike and I love the opportunity to get a great deal and try out new-to-us restaurants during Restaurant Week. More than 180 restaurants are participating this time around (two-course lunch menus are $10, $15 or $20; three-course dinners are $25, $35 or $45).

Brooklyn Girl, which is offering a $35 dinner menu, started things off by bringing a simple bowl of buttery, salty popcorn to the table. Between that and the canvas portraits of Christopher Walken and Woody Allen (painted by one of the waiters!) gazing down at us from the walls, we felt right at home, Brooklyn-style.

Mike and I debated over which was our favorite bite of the evening — this was mine, Bacon Wrapped Vietnamese Meatballs with Quick Tiger Slaw and sweet chili glaze. The meatballs were made with shrimp and pork, they were incredible. I should mention, by the way, that there are a variety of dishes representing different cultures throughout the menu, reflecting the diversity of food you can get in Brooklyn.

Ok, oysters aren’t on the Restaurant Week menu, but Brooklyn Girl is also an oyster bar and we couldn’t resist ordering some of these beauties.

Our server recommended the Deep Fried Pickles, which were excellent — they were pickled Brussels sprouts, carrots and cauliflower in a really light, tempura-like batter with a thyme-walnut yogurt sauce for dipping. I’m pretty sure we finished these off!
Colorado Lamb Sirloin at Brooklyn Girl, San DiegoOk, so here’s where the Pommes Anna come in…they were served alongside the Colorado Lamb Sirloin entrée (that layered block at the upper left). I’m not sure how many potato layers there were in there — 10? 20? They were a real treat…so much so that I came home and made my own!

Mike likes meat a little rarer than I do — this was medium-rare — but I really liked this dish too. The lamb was served over an eggplant purée and za’atar creamed spinach (which wasn’t overly heavy, like creamed spinach can sometimes be).

Pan Roasted Sea Bass at Brooklyn Girl, San Diego
I chose the Pan Roasted Seabass, which was served with cauliflower couscous, artichokes, a rather sweet slice of Tahitian Squash on the bottom and preserved lemon beurre blanc. My piece of fish was a touch overcooked, but the flavors were wonderful.

And finally…this masterpiece. I don’t remember its exact name, but I’ve been calling it the Peanut Butter Mousse Bombe — the chocolate shell is filled with peanut butter mousse and chocolate mousse, and there’s also a smattering of crunchy Oreo crumbs along the edge. I take it back…I did love the Bacon-Wrapped Vietnamese Meatballs, but I think this bombe edges it out for my favorite of the night.
Use a mandoline (carefully!) to get ultra thin potato slices
Back to today’s Grilled Potatoes Anna…Potatoes Anna (or Pommes Anna) is a classic French dish made simply from layered potatoes and a great deal of butter. At Brooklyn Girl the portions were served as cubes cut from a larger potato cake, but I chose to use ramekins to make individually-sized little stacks. If you’ve got a mandoline, now is the time to bring it out, as you need ultra thin potato slices for this dish.
Grill the Potatoes Anna in ramekins on the panini press
After being tossed in melted butter, the potatoes get layered into ramekins and cooked right on the panini press. The final step, once the cooked potatoes are inverted from their molds, is to crisp up the outsides directly on the grill. True, you could always bake these potatoes in the oven — that would be far more traditional — but then you’d miss out on the pretty grill marks!


Grilled Potatoes Anna

By Kathy Strahs,

Adapted from the Mini Herbed Pommes Anna recipe from Bon Appetit

Prep time: 15 minutes | Cook time: 40 minutes | Total time: 55 minutes

Yield: 4 servings


  • 3 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
  • 3/4 pound small waxy potatoes, such as Yukon Gold
  • 3/4 teaspoon kosher salt
  • Freshly ground black pepper


  1. Brush the bottom and sides of four 6-ounce ramekins (3 1/2 inches in diameter) with melted butter. Line the bottoms with parchment paper rounds (make an easy stencil by tracing around the bottom of a ramekin), and brush more butter on the parchment.
  2. Heat the panini press to medium-high heat.
  3. Carefully slice the potatoes very thinly (less than 1/16-inch thick) with a mandoline. Transfer the slices to a medium bowl and pour the remaining melted butter over them. Season with salt and pepper and toss to coat well.
  4. Layer the potato slices in an overlapping circular pattern, dividing them evenly among the ramekins.
  5. Transfer the ramekins to the panini press and close the lid so that the upper plate is resting on the rims of the ramekins. Grill the potatoes until they’re fork tender and beginning to brown along the edges (open the press to check the potatoes periodically), about 35 minutes (exact time will vary, as all panini presses heat differently).
  6. Carefully remove each ramekin from the panini press with a potholder – keep the panini press on. Place a plate on top of each ramekin and invert the ramekin to release the potatoes – they should slide out easily. Discard the parchment.
  7. Transfer the potato stacks back over to the panini press and close the lid so that the upper plate is resting on top without much pressure. Grill the potatoes until the outside is crisped with grill marks, about 2 minutes. Serve immediately.


Many thanks to San Diego Restaurant Week for hosting my husband I for dinner at Brooklyn Girl! Check out the special prix fixe menus at this and more than 180 other restaurants Jan 19-24.


KathyPanini Happy, online since 2008, is more than just a sandwich blog. Here, you'll find hundreds of my original panini recipes, my guide to choosing a panini press and a whole lot of other creative uses for the panini press.
~ Kathy Strahs
>> About Me

All-Time Reader Favorites!

Panini 101

Recent Posts


Permission Policy

All recipes, text and photographs on this site are the original creations and property of Panini Happy. Do not post or publish anything from this site without full credit and a direct link to the original post. with any requests or questions.

Browse Panini

Leave a Comment


  1. Mike from Class wrote:

    You can’t go wrong with grilled potatoes and butter – great technique!

    Posted 1.18.14 Reply
  2. I seriously want these potatoes and your dinner at Brooklyn Girl now!!

    Posted 1.19.14 Reply
  3. I want these grilled potatoes right now! They sound simple but amazing!

    Posted 1.19.14 Reply
  4. These are fantastic. I love potatoes and need to make these asap.

    Posted 1.26.14 Reply
  5. These are fabulous. I love the simplicity of the potatoes and the final dish is gorgeous!

    Posted 1.27.14 Reply