Keeping it Simple

I feel myself heading into a phase – a “back to basics” phase. Some panini out there are just getting too frou-frou for me. Maybe it’s the fact that we call them panini rather than just grilled sandwiches. They kind of sound fancy, so maybe we should fill them with fancy ingredients? It’s certainly tempting. I’ll be the first to admit that I’ve succumbed to the urge to use a roasted garlic aioli here and a dill-watercress salad there. But are hoity-toity ingredients really what panini are about? I don’t think they have to be. My favorite panini recipes thus far have been the ones with the shortest ingredient lists and nearly no measurements – just simple, quality ingredients combined to create something wonderful.

It was this newfound “back to basics” mentality that led me to make a sandwich based on the simple, classic Italian caprese salad. Heirloom tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, some good extra-virgin olive oil and lemon zest – what more do you need? Want to skip ahead? Click here for the final recipe.

Tomato, Mozzarella & Basil Panini – Attempt #1

  • Bread: French baguette
  • Meat: None
  • Cheese: Fresh mozzarella
  • Condiments: Extra-virgin olive oil
  • “Goodies”: Heirloom tomatoes, fresh basil leaves

THE INSPIRATION: You know, Gordon Ramsay isn’t always the fire-tempered, abusive, profane (well, he is always profane) chef that he appears to be on “Hell’s Kitchen”. Or maybe I should say those aren’t his only traits. I think the man just has high standards and low tolerance for mediocrity. This is far more apparent on his British show, “Ramsay’s Kitchen Nightmares”, which I have been watching religiously on BBC America as of late. He still verbally beats these restaurant owners and head chefs down to tears (I’ve learned lots of fantastic new swear phrases!), but once that’s over with he seems genuinely dedicated to helping them turn their businesses around, improve their food and usually departs on very friendly terms. Usually.

Why do I bring up Chef Ramsay? His advice in almost every “Kitchen Nightmares” episode – sans the screaming – is to focus on simple, honest food. Dispense with pretentiousness and unnecessary flourishes. He believes in letting good, quality ingredients stand on their own. I can really appreciate that philosophy. Keep it about the food, not the cook. Wise words to cook by. So here’s to f*&%ing simplicity in cooking!

THE PREPARATION: Slicing into an heirloom tomato is a little like opening a present on Christmas Day – there’s a moment of excitement as you get to peer in and see what’s inside. The often – I’ll say it – ugly exterior doesn’t provide many clues. I was pleased to see, as I began slicing into my bulbous red and brown tomato that it came out kind of heart-shaped and was dotted in an almost lace-like seed pattern. Pretty! I removed the seeds so the bread wouldn’t get too soggy. With Chef Ramsay’s Scottish bellow echoing in my ear, “TAYYYYSTE your FUUUUD!!”, I sampled a little slice. So sweet!

At least the first tomato was. The second one I’d bought, a bright green one, was super-acidic and way too firm. Woopsie! Well, that’s why I buy a variety of ingredients when I go shopping for these panini 🙂 I stuck with the pretty heart-shaped one.

Speaking of variety, I also bought two different kinds of mozzarella – one fresh and one low-moisture. Giada De Laurentiis just advised last week on the Food Network against using fresh mozzarella in dishes where you are looking to control the moisture. Generally, I’d say panini would qualify as such a situation. Still, I really love how fresh mozzarella tastes in caprese salads so I threw caution to the wind and sliced some up. Left the low-moisture stuff in the reserves just in case.

THE CONSTRUCTION: Since the tomatoes were the featured attraction on this sandwich, I chose a French baguette for bread based on texture rather than flavor. A nice big crunch was going to be a great complement to the relatively soft fillings.

Olive oil is usually an integral part of an insalata caprese, with a good amount of its fruity goodness drizzled over the top. For the panini version, I still wanted this great flavor but I thought a measured approach was in order. So I opted to brush some oil directly onto the insides of my baguette – that way I’d still have the great flavor without an excessive amount of oil seeping into the bread.

I lay down a couple of big, fresh basil leaves and added my lacy heart-shaped tomatoes on top. Then I seasoned the tomatoes with some sea salt and black pepper as well as some grated lemon zest. The lemon is kind of an optional ingredient in a caprese – sometimes you see it, sometimes you don’t – but I really wanted to go for big fresh flavor on this sandwich and lemon always delivers. Lastly, I added two slices of my fresh mozzarella, closed up the top and set it on the grill at medium-high heat for about 5 minutes.

THE RESULTS: Simply delicious! I’m glad I added the lemon, it added a really nice tart accent to the sweet tomatoes. Even though I used fresh mozzarella, rather than the low-moisture kind, the sandwich didn’t get too wet. The cheese melted quickly and beautifully and the slight saltiness was a nice complement to the other flavors. My toasty baguette delivered as expected, with a nice big crunch in each bite. All in all, I think Chef Ramsay would be proud (perhaps). 🙂

> Get the final recipe!

Be featured on Panini Happy! Click here to find out how.


KathyPanini Happy, online since 2008, is more than just a sandwich blog. Here, you'll find hundreds of my original panini recipes, my guide to choosing a panini press and a whole lot of other creative uses for the panini press.
~ Kathy Strahs
>> About Me

All-Time Reader Favorites!

Panini 101

Recent Posts


Permission Policy

All recipes, text and photographs on this site are the original creations and property of Panini Happy. Do not post or publish anything from this site without full credit and a direct link to the original post. with any requests or questions.

Browse Panini

Leave a Comment


  1. Grace wrote:

    this is my go-to sandwich when i don’t feel like a heavy meal, especially when i can get my hands on some heirloom tomatoes. more often than not, they’re absolutely luscious and utterly enjoyable. nice *&#%@!# panini! 🙂

    Posted 5.5.08 Reply
  2. You said keep it simple. What the ^&*( is with those white egg like things, doesn’t seem very simple to me well at least you chose the best bread.

    Simple Grilled Cheese Panini
    Extra light virgin olive oil
    Baguette – Cut in half to right size of a pan
    Lettuce – Sliced just enough to cover the bread
    Prosciutto – Best damn meat for it
    Cheese of your choice (Mozerella or Jalapeno
    being the best)
    Mayo or BBQ sauce

    1. Slice the bread in the middle (duh step)

    2. Put some virgin olive oil in a bowl

    3. Cover outer layers of baguette with virgin olive oil using a brush.
    4. You need 2 pans set the heat up on high to heat up the pan for about 4 minutes after 4 minutes take it down to about 50% heat. One
    pan needs to be big other one smaller of course.

    5. Once you have your layers covered in Oil and heat down to half place one bread side down on the pan and put the meat and cheese on the baguette and place the other half of the bread on top. Take the small pan and press down on it to squeeze your baguette down until the whole thing is flattened. Press the pan down a bit and fry for about 5 minutes. Flip your baguette to the other side and do the same step (you will know if it was fried right when the bread is golden brown but not too dark!)

    6. Place the Panini on your plate and open it up careful the whole thing will be very hot! Place your lettuce, tomatoes and add a bit of mayo on the lettuce or bbq sauce and close it back up.

    7. Have one hell of a meal and don’t forget to clean up or to turn off the stove.

    Posted 6.27.09 Reply
  3. I am sorry one more extra note. Do not use anything but Teflon pans or you can really mess things up including the pans.

    Posted 6.27.09 Reply