It’s my turn to rise and throw up my arms for the “pretty food” wave! Starting the wave were two of my favorite food bloggers, Erin from Erin Cooks and Katy from Sugarlaws, who each incorporated sweet little heart motifs into their creations. Erin cut out heart-shaped chocolate chip cookies to make her XOXO Ice Cream Sandwiches and Katy used a heart stencil to give her Cinnamon Pancakes extra-romantic appeal. So when I stumbled across the cutest little flower-shaped sandwich cutters at Williams-Sonoma this past weekend (a very dangerous place to shop when you’ve got time on your hands and you write a food blog!), I was eager to join the trend and make pretty panini!
My Smoked Turkey, Gruyère & Membrillo Panini is smoky, sweet, salty and nutty – the combination really works. In a Panini Happy first, I went with two types of bread – a sourdough and a dark rye – to add to the “layered” look as well as bring in more flavor.
Are you familiar with membrillo, a.k.a. quince paste? Myself, I’d never heard of quince or membrillo until I found the spread in the cheese section at my local Bristol Farms store. Roaming in this section is a bit of a grazer’s paradise, with little tasting stations every few feet. There was a station featuring manchego cheese, which I love, and they were cross-selling little tubs of a reddish-purplish condiment to go with it. Quince is a very tart fruit, related to apples and pears. Once cooked, it’s sweet and floral. The combination of the tangy manchego with the sugary-sweet quince paste was incredible! So I took home a tub in the hopes that I’d find other cheeses – some that melt a little better than manchego – to pair it with on panini. Gruyère, with its salty nuttiness, turned out to be one such cheese.
Truth be told, pressing these floral shapes out of bread and turkey wasn’t entirely a walk in the park. Ideally, it would have been great if the cutter were a little sharper. But then I guess it wouldn’t pass standards for a kids’ tool! So I ended up helping things along with my paring knife. I’d contemplated cutting out the sandwiches after they were grilled, but I envisioned a crumby mess ensuing. Pre-cutting the individual shapes worked out great – and for those enticed by The Pioneer Woman’s Eggs in a Hole last week, you end up with lots of pretty holes!
My husband, sister and I enjoyed our sandwich flowers with Baked Carrot Oven Fries from 101 Cookbooks and a simple green salad. “What a pretty dinner!” exclaimed my husband. Mission accomplished.

Smoked Turkey, Gruyère & Membrillo Panini
Serves 4
INGREDIENTS:
4 slices sourdough bread
4 slices dark rye bread
Membrillo (quince paste)*, room temperature
12 slices smoked turkey breast
4 oz. Gruyère cheese, grated
DIRECTIONS:
Preheat panini grill to medium-high heat (375 degrees).
For each sandwich: Spread membrillo onto a slice of the sourdough bread. Add 3 slices of turkey and about an ounce of cheese. Top with a slice of dark rye. Grill 4-5 minutes until the cheese melts and grill marks appear. Serve immediately and enjoy!
NOTE: If you decide to cut the panini into shapes with a sandwich cutter, as I did, I recommend cutting out the bread and turkey pieces prior to assembling the sandwich.
* If you’re feeling up to making your own membrillo, there’s a great recipe for it at Simply Recipes.
>Want more panini recipes? Check out the Recipe Index for a list of all recipes on Panini Happy.


Yup, it's a panini blog! Here, you'll find more than 80 of my original 









{ 15 comments… read them below or add one }
Okay those are dang adorable. Just adorable.
[Reply]
I have that same cookie cutter in my cupboard (along with 75 other shapes that I use for the cookies we donate) — now, why haven’t I thought of using it for anything other than cookies? This is a great way to make a healthy sandwich more appealing to my grandkids!
[Reply]
Ah! So cute! I love the shape. And no crust. Yum Yum!
PS: Thank you for linking to my ice cream sandwiches. I’m glad that you enjoyed them.
[Reply]
super cute! love flowers and the flavors sound to go really well together. need to stop reading as it is making me hungry!
[Reply]
What is membrillo?
[Reply]
Natasha – Perhaps I didn’t describe it well enough in the post – it’s a paste made from quince, a pear-like tart fruit that turns sweet when cooked. The membrillo that I used incorporated plums as well. Very tasty with cheese!
[Reply]
aren’t you crafty! i love the shape, obviously. quince paste sounds extremely appealing to me and i think turkey and gruyere make a marvelous combination. apparently i’m smitten with this panini.
[Reply]
If that’s not the cutest little sandwich, I don’t know what is! Love it!
[Reply]
This is so cute! It’s just like the egg shapers I found on Coffee and Vanilla. I never would have though to shape my sandwich!!
[Reply]
Oh, no, I know what quince is, we have a few quince trees in the garden of our country house. I’ve just never heard of membrillo before. The ironic thing is that I’ve now googled it and discovered it’s a dessert we make every year and always have in the house, only I never knew that was it’s name! Lol!
[Reply]
Hillary – Those egg shapers are so cute!! Gee, we almost have no excuse to eat rectangular food anymore
[Reply]
I’m so happy that I found your blog! One of my readers clued me into it. I love, love, love paninis! I’m excited to look through your past posts!
[Reply]
Well, if that isnt just the most adorable little panini I’ve ever seen… SUPER cute!
[Reply]
So adorable! And i can almost taste the flavors together–what a delicious combo!
[Reply]
I used to use little cutters to make shapes with carrot rounds. Buy big carrots, slice them no thicker than a couple of millimetres, then cut the shapes. Made the kids love to eat carrots!
[Reply]